Hidden Foodie Gems in Uptown Westerville (Locally-Owned Restaurants That You Might Have Missed)

If you’ve already fallen in love with the pizza and coffee spots that make Uptown Westerville such a favorite, there’s even more to explore just around the corner. This historic district is packed with locally owned restaurants and specialty stops that bring people together over great food and friendly service.

Here are a few must-try hidden gems that locals can’t get enough of:

Uptown Deli & Brew

Tucked right on State Street, Uptown Deli & Brew is the definition of local flavor. By day, it’s a deli known for hearty sandwiches stacked with fresh meats and house-made spreads. By night, it transforms into the home of Temperance Row Brewing Company, serving craft beers brewed on site. Try the “Temperance Turkey” sandwich and a flight of their signature ales — you’ll see why it’s a hometown favorite.

Meza Wine Shop

If your ideal evening involves a good glass of wine and even better company, Meza Wine Shop is your place. This cozy spot offers tastings, classes, and a thoughtful selection of wines from around the world — all curated by a team that makes everyone feel like a regular. Whether you’re picking up a bottle for dinner or enjoying a wine-and-cheese night with friends, Meza delivers both sophistication and warmth.

Schneider’s Bakery (Bonus Classic!)

You can’t talk about Uptown without mentioning Schneider’s Bakery, a Westerville icon since 1957. Whether you stop by early in the morning for fresh donuts or grab a box after dinner, it’s a nostalgic taste of hometown sweetness that never disappoints.

Why Uptown Westerville Shines in the Locally-Owned Restaurant Scene

What makes Uptown’s dining scene so special isn’t just the food — it’s the people. Every restaurant, café, and shop owner adds their own story to this walkable, welcoming district. It’s a place where you can meet friends for coffee, toast a special occasion, or just enjoy an evening stroll with something delicious in hand.

So next time you’re in Uptown Westerville, skip the chain restaurants and support a few of these locally-owned restaurant gems. You’ll leave with a full stomach and maybe a few new favorite spots.